My mother-in-law and sister-in-law came down to take Allison to the Outback Bowl on New Year's Day since they are all big Auburn fans. We knew that we wanted to go downtown for new years but could not decide on where to eat. We finally choose
Hillview Grill. We had been previously, and enjoyed it a lot.
We made reservations for 8:30 with no problems about a week ago. When we arrived about 20 minutes early, we were sat nearly immediately. When we called we were told that it would be a limited, but not prixe fix menu. The menu was huge! There were 6 (or maybe 8, can't remember for sure) appetizers plus a dozen or so entree selections. In addition, each entree came with a soup or salad and 2 sides! And the prices were really reasonable to boot.
We started with glasses of wine, rather than going with a bottle. Allison had the fume blanc (Ferrari-Carrano) and I had a glass of Omaka Springs Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand. My sister-in-law picked a cabernet (Snap Dragon) and the mother-in-law initially went with a merlot (Santa Ema Reserve) but it was apparently a bottle that had been opened for a bit and so she switched to the Snap Dragon as well. The waitress was very prompt at switching and even commented that they did not want anybody to be unhappy with their wine, which I thought was a nice touch.
Seeing as how the entrees were going to have a good bit of food (more on that in a second) we decided that the 4 of us would simply split the fried green tomatoes. These were lightly breaded and fried, served with spicy remolaude sauce and crab meat. Unfortunately, there were only 3 tomatoes but we divided them up anyway and everybody was happy. These were very, very good. The only minor complaint was that they could have stood another minute or so of frying to really firm them up... they were just a touch on the soggy side.
We each went a different direction for our entree. I had bacon wrapped scallops, with grilled asparagus, sauteed spinach and lobster bisque. Allison choose a salmon piccata style with grilled asparagus, broccoli with hollandaise and lobster bisque. The mother-in-law and sister-in-law both had a wedge salad, and then went with a lobster and shrimp linguine and filet-mignon respectively.
Normally with a scallop entree I expect 2 or perhaps 3 scallops (when dealing with U-10 size). Nope, not this time. Count them all... there were 4 scallops plated up along with a generous portion of spinach and about half a dozen asparagus stalks. Wow! The scallops were perfectly cooked - seared nicely on the outside and still juicy on the inside. Both of the sides were also perfect.
Allison said her salmon was delightful. It looked like it might have been an entire salmon filet on her plate it was so large.
My mother-in-law's lobster/shrimp linguine looked like they accidently put two orders on one plate. Seriously. The plate was probably 8-9 inches square and it was completely full. There were 2 4-oz lobster tails plus a bunch of shrimp, vegetables and linguine. There is no way the any normal person could have eaten all of that food.
And the sister-in-laws steak was perfectly cooked, covered with mushrooms and accompanied by twice baked potatoes. The steak was probably 8 ounces, if not more.
We could not finish anywhere near all of the food that was brought out. It was amazing! And everything that I tried was perfectly cooked - nothing over or under done. We split the check, and Allison and I got out with all of our food and 4 glasses of wine for right at $100 before tip.
The service was very good, even considering it was new year's eve. Whenever we needed something, the waitress was there and the rest of the time was discreetly absent.
Hillview Grill is fast becoming our favorite restaurant in downtown Sarasota. If you have not been, you need to make it your new year's resolution to get down there sooner rather than later.
Cheers!