Allison and I had the opportunity last night to attend a wine dinner at the Lido Beach Grille last night featuring a menu of Long Island inspired food and Long Island wines. We've been looking forward to this for a couple of weeks.
First, the wines. We were tasting
Bedell Cellars wines from Cutchogue, Long Island. They had three different bottles there, and we tasted two of the three:
2007 Taste White
This was an interesting blend of 58% Chardonnay, 16% Sauvignon Blanc, 15% Viognier and 11% Gewurztraminer. The nose revealed a sharp acidity and floral overtones, notably jasmine. On the palate there was a lot of citrus, melon and green apples. It was somewhat medium bodied, with a hint of sweetness and spice. A very good summer white. The tasting sheet noted the price at $49/bottle, so I'm guessing it would be $20-25 retail.
2006 Taste Red
Another blend, this one is 56% Merlot, 25% Cabernet Sauvignon and 19% Syrah. On the nose there was a lot of bright fruit which at first scared us, but the palate was well balanced between plum and cherry, with notes of cocoa, bell pepper and finished with an earthy oak. The tannins were somewhat gritty on the finish.
The third wine, which we didn't taste was listed as 2005 Musee but the website is showing information for the 2006, so I'm not sure which one was actually being poured.
The menu was 3 courses - appetizer, entree and dessert - and included:
Appetizers- Fresh field greens with roasted chestnuts, farmers goat cheese fritters, grilled strawberries and shaved fennel minted strawberry vinaigrette
- Shinnecock Quahog chowder, a tomato based thick and chunky clam chowder
We both had the chowder, and it was very good even though I'm not a big fan of tomato based chowders. There were lots of chunky tomators and clams in a tomato broth full of herbs. It was presented in a deep bowl accentuated with a clam shell in the center. This was probably the best part of the meal for both of us.
Entrees - Line caught wild striped bass with horseradish potato crust, served with light lemon-herb butter and fresh long island vegetables
- Roasted Long Island duckling with three berry reduction, corn pudding and brussels sprouts
- Stuffed Montauk flounder with Peconic Bay blue crab claw meat and Robins Island oysters and fresh Long Island Vegetables
Allison went with the flounder and thought that it was just okay. The presentation was great, but the flavors didn't seem to really complement each other that well and the fish tasted fairly fishy. I had the bass, and thought too that it was a bit fishy for my taste. The potato crust was excellent however.
Desserts- Cutchague strawberry shortcake with fresh whipped cream
- Wickams Farms apple strudel
I went with the shortcake, and while it was good it really tasted a lot like Sara Lee. The cream was very fresh and light. Allison had one bite of her strudel and proclaimed that it was not very good. No one commented or asked her why she didn't eat it which was a serious oversight in our opinion.
So, we were less than impressed with this dinner overall. The wines were very good, and depending on pricing we would probably buy one or both of them retail. However, there were several issues with the dinner that made the whole evening somewhat of a bust for us. First, there was only one glass of wine included with the dinner. Granted, it was a full glass and not just a tasting portion, but I would have rather paid a little bit more and gotten both the white and red. Also, the third wine (Musee) was only available by the bottle and was $94! The next thing that was annoying was the fact that they had one table for 10 (which was a group) and the rest of the tables were for 2 or 4 --- so we sat by ourselves. One of the reasons we enjoy going to these events is to meet and interact with people. I know a lot of restaurants automatically include gratuity on large parties, although I'm not entirely sure that I agree with that policy, but I didn't find that the service approached being worth the 20% that they tacked on. Finally, the manager who was working, and said that she had a hand in putting this together, immediately sloughed off any responsibility when we made a constructive comment to her.
Bottom line is that we enjoyed trying some new wines but the restaurant experience was sorely lacking. We don't plan on returning to Lido Beach Grille.
Cheers!